AFL: umpire got O’Brien call wrong

By on April 15, 2013

Please install the most recent Flash participant

[To view Flash please enable JavaScript and Flash.]

O'Brian Hodge

Fallacious name … Harry O’Brien penalised for colliding with Luke Hodge. Provide: Information Restricted

The AFL has thrown out Harry O’Brien’s report and conceded he should have gotten a free kick in opposition to Luke Hodge.

A collision between the two avid gamers sparked widespread confusion after O’Brien used to be once prompt for difficult habits at the MCG on Sunday.

Please install the most recent Flash participant

[To view Flash please enable JavaScript and Flash.]

the selection contradicted a model new interpretation that will have to have resulted in a free kick for the Collingwood defender for forceful contact under the knees.

A smothered kick landed in between O’Brien and Hodge and every participant, coming from a number of metres far from every different, charged on the footy.

O’Brien went low, Hodge slid in head first and got to the ball a fraction of a Second quicker than his opponent.

Hodge’s head crashed in to O’Brien’s shin and O’Brien went flying.

Releasing the wholesome evaluation panel’s verdict nowadays, the AFL talked about the umpire acquired the rule of thumb backwards.

“After viewing all available footage and talking to the umpire who laid the report on the day, it was once the view of the panel that Hodge’s motion contributed to the contact under the knees on O’Brien and the Collingwood participant will have to have got a free kick,” the panel talked about.

“It used to be as soon as the panel’s view that O’Brien’s actions were not reportable and no extra motion used to be as soon as taken.”


Entice Rex Hunt on Open Mike, Brad Scott joins the On the Sofa crew and all of it kicks off with AFL 360 at 7.30pm (EST) on Fox Footy.


Hodge’s teammate Jordan Lewis mentioned this present day he used to be mystified by way of the record.

“the best way in which it may be been defined to us is, for individuals who slide in and get in touch with any individual entrance on inside the legs, it’s a free kick to the man who’s standing over the ball,” Lewis mentioned these days.

“that’s what now we have been advised.

“it will be excellent to appear the result as of late, on account of it is going to Provide us further clarification on what the rule of thumb in truth is.

“The umpires can have made a mistake, we have no concept,” he instructed the AFL site.

“From what we now have bought been suggested, we can only attempt to take care of our toes and Not slide in as rather a lot, and No Longer put ourselves in the position to provide away a free kick.”

The Twittersphere went into meltdown after the incident, with requires umpire Heath Ryan to be demoted subsequent week.

Essendon’s Jason Winderlich voiced player considerations when he tweeted quickly after: “The Hodge and Harry O contest has confused me much more?!!”.

Whereas @getemgaz encapsulated the mood of the lovers when he tweeted: “he (O’Brien) must be prompt, but additionally get a free kick. (It’s) Encouraging individuals to run into any individual who locations their head over the ball”.

Whether Or Not Or No Longer these views are right or Flawed in the eyes of AFL officials they show, if nothing else, that no one is aware about needless to say what’s going on.

It came after a first quarter incident yesterday wherein Magpie Jamie Elliott was once as soon as awarded a free kick after Ben Stratton slid in to a contest.

But Elliott used to be as soon as the method of kicking the ball off the bottom and in seasons prior he most indubitably would have given away the free kick.


News Game Data

You must be logged in to post a comment Login

Leave a Reply